The hold smelled of tar and old rope and something else underneath it, something sour that Vincent couldn't yet name but Nate could. He'd smelled it before. Bilgewater sitting too long over cargo no one wanted found.

Nate went down the ladder first, lantern in one hand, the other braced against the rungs. Vincent followed, quieter, his bare feet finding the wood without a sound, the way he did everything.

"Careful of the second crate," Nate said without turning around. "Sorrel's man nailed it shut twice. Man only does that when he's hiding something he's ashamed of."

Vincent didn't answer. He was already looking past Nate, at the shape of the hold in the lantern light, at the crates stacked wrong, too careful, too deliberate for a working ship's cargo.

Nate set the lantern on a barrel and crouched by the nearest crate, working the lid with the flat of his knife. He talked while he worked, the way he always did, filling silence because silence made other men nervous and it seemed to Vincent that Nate had simply never learned to stop.

"Lou doesn't know I know what he did for me," Nate said, and then stopped himself, like a man who'd stepped off a ledge he hadn't meant to find. He worked the knife under the lid instead of finishing the thought. "You know Lou and I have sailed together eight years now," he said instead, the words coming a little too quick. "Since we were younger than you'd believe looking at us now. I was near enough your age when we started, if you can imagine that. Skinnier too, if you can imagine that."

The lid gave. Nate didn't look inside yet. He was watching Vincent from the corner of his eye instead.

"First year we sailed together, I got sick," Nate went on. "Fever, the kind that turns a man's skin yellow and his mind to soup. We were three days from any port worth the name. Lou didn't know me from any other deckhand back then. No reason to spend a single coin of goodwill on me." He paused, working the second nail free. "He gave up his own berth so I could stay dry belowdecks. Slept on deck himself for six nights in weather that would've put a healthy man in the ground. Never told me until a year later. I found out from the quartermaster, not from him."

Vincent's eyes moved from the crate to Nate's face, just for a moment.

"I didn't earn that," Nate said. "Didn't do a single thing to deserve it. He just did it. That's the part that took me years to understand. Some men don't wait to see if you're worth it first."

He lifted the lid the rest of the way.

For a moment neither of them spoke. The lantern light caught metal, dull and dark, half buried under oiled cloth. Nate reached in and drew out a single iron fitting, curved and heavy, the kind of piece that belonged bolted to a hull rather than sitting loose in a crate three ships away from where it should have been.

Stamped into the metal, worn but legible, was a mark Vincent had never seen before and Nate had.

A ship's crest. Cyphir.

Nate went very still.

Behind them, footsteps on the ladder. Lou's voice, low. "Nate. What did you find."

Neither of them answered right away.

Lou came down the last few rungs faster than the ladder wanted to allow, boots striking wood hard enough that Vincent stepped back without meaning to. He crossed the hold in four strides and stopped in front of Nate, in front of the crate, in front of the fitting still resting in Nate's open palm.

He didn't reach for it right away. He looked at it the way a man looks at something he has been told for years does not exist, and now cannot stop seeing.

"That bolt pattern," Lou said, quiet, almost to himself. "Four holes, not six. My father argued with every shipwright in the yard over that. Said six was wasted iron on a fitting that size. Nobody builds them that way but him."

"That's ours," he said again, louder. Not a question.

"Aye." Nate's voice had lost its easy edge. "Found it under oiled cloth. Wasn't meant to be seen."

Lou took it from him then, turned it over once in the lantern light. His thumb passed across the stamped crest the way a man touches a scar he's forgotten he has, until something reminds him. His jaw worked. He said nothing for a long moment, and in that silence the hold felt smaller than it had a minute before.

"Six ships," he said finally, quiet. "They took six ships that night. Near finished, every one of them. My father spent eleven years building the yard that made them." He set the fitting down on the crate's edge, gentler than the moment seemed to call for, as if it might still break. "I always thought whoever took them broke them down for parts. Sold the iron. Burned the rest for the insult of it."

"Not broken down," Nate said. "Not this piece, anyhow. This is a hull fitting. Recent work, too, look at the wear on it. Somebody's been sailing a Cyphir-built ship for years and calling it their own."

Lou's eyes came up, and for the first time since he'd hit the bottom of the ladder, he seemed to remember Vincent was standing there.

"You knew Sorrel sailed with Cortez," Lou said. It wasn't quite an accusation, but it wasn't far from one either. "Didn't you."

Vincent held his gaze the way he'd learned to, steady, giving nothing away for free. But something in his shoulders had changed since the crate opened, a looseness where there was usually none.

"I didn't know," he said. "I suspected. Cortez doesn't share a hold with a man he doesn't trust with something." He looked at the fitting on the crate's edge, then back at Lou. "I didn't know it was your father's yard. I swear that."

Lou studied him a moment longer, then nodded, once, and some of the tension went out of the hold with it.

"Find the rest of it," Lou said to Nate. "Every crate. I want to know how much of my father's work is sitting in this ship's bones."

Nate moved to obey, already prying at the second crate, but Vincent didn't follow him right away. He stood a moment longer beside the first, looking at the little iron crest as though it had asked him a question he didn't yet have the answer to.

"Your father built this," he said, half to himself.

"He did." Lou's voice had gone rough at the edges.

Vincent picked up the fitting, turned it over once the way Lou had, then set it carefully back down, aligned exactly where it had rested before, like something he wanted kept safe rather than kept moving.

"Then we'll account for every piece," Vincent said.

It wasn't much. It wasn't a confession or an apology or anything close to the words Lou might have wanted from him. But it was the first thing Vincent had ever offered without being asked, and Lou heard it for what it was.

Nate had gone quiet at the second crate, and when Vincent turned to see why, he found him crouched low, one hand braced on the wood, staring down at something he hadn't touched yet.

"Lou," Nate said, and there was nothing easy left in his voice at all. "You'll want to see this one yourself."

Lou crossed the hold again, slower this time, as though some part of him already understood that whatever came next would not be finished tonight, and might not be finished for a long while yet.

He looked down into the crate and went still in a way Vincent had not yet seen from him.

"That's not my father's work," Lou said. "That's my father's hand."